The prize will be awarded to the player who returns the best Gross Stableford points scored at the Annual Meeting. Should a competitor win both this prize and the Hayco Trophy (net) the net prize takes precedence over the Scratch Prize.
| Year | Winner | Club |
|---|---|---|
| 1950 | RN Knowles | Huyton & Prescot |
| 1951 | RS Kirkpatrick | Birkdale |
| 1952 | IGW Newington | Southport & Ainsdale |
| 1953 | AL Bentley | Hesketh |
| 1954 | J Stanway Johnson | Childwall |
| 1955 | AL Bentley | Hesketh |
| 1956 | AL Bentley | Hesketh |
| tied with | E Lunt | Childwall |
| 1957 | AL Bentley | Hesketh |
| 1958 | MA Reece | West Derby |
| tied with | A McCormack | Dean Wood |
| 1959 | JA Graham | Royal Liverpool |
| 1960 | TA Cowdy | West Lancashire |
| 1961 | J Search | Woolton |
| 1962 | HL Silverston | Lee Park |
| 1963 | TN Thorpe | Hesketh |
| 1964 | TN Thorpe | Hesketh |
| 1965 | J Stanway Johnson | Childwall |
| 1966 | R Lancaster | Haydock Park |
| 1967 | F Fawcett | Woolton |
| 1968 | F Fawcett | Woolton |
| 1969 | L Wells | Hesketh |
| 1970 | F Fawcett | Woolton |
| 1971 | LC Wolfman | Lee Park |
| 1972 | JD Maher | Huyton & Prescot |
| 1973 | A Bannister | West Derby |
| 1974 | F Fawcett | Woolton |
| 1975 | R Lancaster | Haydock Park |
| 1976 | R Lancaster | Haydock Park |
| tied with | ME Richards | Dean Wood |
| 1977 | DM Marsh | Southport & Ainsdale |
| 1978 | EF Smith | Gathurst |
| 1979 | A Bannister | West Derby |
| 1980 | K Parkin | Dean Wood |
| 1981 | A Bannister | West Derby |
| 1982 | A Bannister | West Derby |
| 1983 | F Harkins | Heswall |
| 1984 | R Lancaster | Haydock Park |
| 1985 | NM Edwards | Bromborough |
| 1986 | NM Edwards | Bromborough |
| 1987 | CF Wilson | Hillside |
| 1988 | A Bannister | West Derby |
| 1989 | CF Caroe | Heswall |
| 1990 | R Galloway | Gathurst |
| 1991 | PH Critchley | Childwall |
| 1992 | NM Edwards | Bromborough |
| 1993 | JP Bevan | Woolton |
| 1994 | R Simm | Caldy |
| 1995 | A Pheasant | Dean Wood |
| 1996 | PH Critchley | Childwall |
| 1997 | AJ Cunnington | Ormskirk |
| 1998 | D Edge | Ormskirk |
| 1999 | AJ Rawlinson | Childwall |
| 2000 | AJ Rawlinson | Childwall |
| 2001 | HA Thomas | Formby |
| 2002 | AJ Cunnington | Ormskirk |
| 2003 | JA Connolly | Wallasey |
| 2004 | DE Walkden | Haydock Park |
| 2005 | JP Jones | Bromborough |
| 2006 | PH Hurst | Widnes |
| 2007 | GL Goodwin | Leasowe |
| 2008 | JE Delves | Dean Wood |
| 2009 | AJ Cunnington | Ormskirk |
| 2010 | GL Goodwin | Leasowe |
| 2011 | GJ Mathieson | Prenton |
| 2012 | I Gregson | Ormskirk |
| 2013 | P Bennett | West Derby |
| 2014 | HP Jones | Heswall |
| 2015 | CM Hulme | Ashton-in-Makerfield |
| 2016 | AJ Davies | Hillside |
| 2017 | C Kerin | Wallasey |
| 2018 | P Bennett | West Derby |
| 2019 | I Jamson | Formby |
| 2020 | Not Played | |
| 2021 | P Darlington | Southport & Ainsdale |
| 2022 | P Bagshaw | Southport & Ainsdale |
| 2023 | A Bowman | Formby |
| 2024 | D Pilkington | Southport & Ainsdale |